I've been very pleased with VeganEssentials, they have a nice selection of items and their service is excellent. Not so much in the craft category, but they've got footwear, personal care items, food, clothing, vitamins, pet supplies, etc.
I've also purchased items from Pangea/The Vegan Store -- they've got a great selection also, and have always seemed very nice to work with.
I highly recommend both!
Rites of Passage